Catch Nicole in Catching Faith 2 now on DVD and streaming, buy your copy here!

Catch Nicole in Catching Faith 2 now on DVD and streaming, buy your copy now!

  • Relationships
  • News From Nicole

    What Do I Do If I Don’t Like a Guy Back?

    While singleness has those days when you wonder, “Where are all the godly guys?!” there are other days when you’re wondering how to turn them down. What if a guy likes you—and you don’t like him back?

    In church or youth group settings, this can be especially difficult. No one wants to sever ties or destroy friendships, but when one person wants a relationship and the other doesn’t, it’s hard not to do so.

    If you’re dealing with a guy who likes you, but you’re just not feeling it, here are three things to do.


    1. Ask Yourself Why

    Before setting up a DTR (“define the relationship”), ask yourself why you aren’t interested. Is it because he isn’t your “type”? Are you judging by appearance? Make sure you aren’t ruling out an otherwise wonderful, godly guy based on issues of preference!

    If, however, you are well acquainted with the guy interested in you and are quite sure he isn’t a good fit, be sure you have your reasons firmly established in your mind. You will need them for the conversation to come.


    2. Be Honest

    They say when you know, you know—and this applies when you know he’s not the right one, too! Many girls dread turning a guy down for a date or refusing his interest in a relationship because they don’t want to hurt him. Though that’s a motive to be admired, it leaves both you and the guy in a tough spot. You’re left figuring out when to “drop the bomb” and he’s spending each passing day with a little extra hope for something more.

    The truth? It hurts him more to lead him on than it does to break it to him honestly. Be honest about your feelings and, if relevant, why you’re not interested in pursuing a relationship. While it will sting at first, in the long run it will release him to find someone who appreciates him for who he is.


    3. Be Careful About “Staying Friends”

    You’ve evaluated your motives. You’ve prepared your reasons. You’ve had the conversation. Here’s where many girls make their biggest mistake: trying to “stay friends” after they’ve turned a guy down. While it seems easy in theory, we forget that feelings don’t go away overnight. When we tell a guy we aren’t interested, but then stay in close proximity to him in the name of “friendship,” we’re not giving him the space he needs to emotionally detach.

    Will it ever go back to friendship? Possibly, but maybe not. Opposite-sex relationships move in one of two directions: forward into romance, or to a respectful emotional distance once each party enters a relationship of his or her own. Even the best guy/girl friendships have to change once one party gets married! So while you might want to preserve the friendship, you have to be willing to let it go if you’re not okay with dating the guy who expressed interest.


    These conversations are difficult and awkward at times, but through them we learn how to honor one another in the awkwardness. Our fear of the awkward tends to make our relationships harder than necessary. By defeating this fear and facing our guy friends with honesty, we do both ourselves and them a favor.

    Phylicia Masonheimer
    Phylicia Masonheimerhttps://phyliciamasonheimer.com/
    Phylicia Masonheimer is an author and speaker teaching women how to discern what is true, discuss the deep stuff, and accomplish God's will for their specific lives. She holds a B.S. in Religion from Liberty University, where she met her husband, Josh, and now lives in northern Michigan with her two daughters, Adeline and Geneva.


    1. If someone asks you out, and you’re not interested, just say so. It might be uncomfortable, being that you don’t want to hurt anyone’s feelings, but it’s better than any other option.

      You absolutely do not owe them any sort of reason. (It’s not bad to think about your reasons for yourself, but you don’t owe those to anyone else.)

      If this situation ruins your friendship, it probably wasn’t a friendship worth having. (It was probably ruined because at least one of the two people involved entered the “friendship” with romantic intent. If you do that, don’t. Let friendships be friendships. Stop treating everyone you meet as prey.)

      In regards to the “staying friends” part; this is just a minor rant:

      I feel like these friendship issues are the result of being overly repressive of one’s sexuality. Don’t do that. Masturbate once in a while. Stop worrying whether or not holding hands is too sexual for your pre-marriage relationship. You’d be amazed what good, lasting friendships you can form with the opposite sex when you stop starting the relationship by thinking of each other as potential love interests.

    Project Inspired

    We here at Project Inspired want to guide and inspire teen girls to be true to themselves and to God. We want to show young girls how to be people of value and confidence – how to be your own best selves – through leading a Christian life. Who are we? We're a team of girls, like you. We edit the site, we post to social media, we hang out in the chat rooms and forums. We talk with you, we listen to you, and we love you!

    Read On

    4 Powerful Things You Didn’t Know About Women in the Early Church

    When we talk about women and the church, the conversation usually descends into a discussion of gender roles. While I’ve discussed women and the...

    10 Amazingly Delicious Hot Chocolate Recipes to Try This Season

    Grab your best mug, the coziest blanket, and your favorite movie! As temperatures wind down and the holidays close in, who wouldn't go for...

    The Greatest Gift You Can Give Your Family

    The greatest gift you can give your family is quality time.  No amount of presents, the coolest new toy or even money is as valuable...

    50 Things to Do When You’re Single for the Holidays

    Are you single for the holidays? Is "cuddling season" inapplicable to you? Are you getting "all the feels" this time of year? Well, I've got news for...

    10 One-Sentence Reminders for When You Need a Reminder of God’s Faithfulness

    Do you ever feel like God is distant? Or do you have a lack of desire to get into the Word? We all have...


    Stay connected with Project Inspired.